X

David Sibley

Distinguishing Philadelphia and Red-eyed Vireos by song: Is it possible?

Possible? It might be, but most of the widely published “differences” are too subjective and/or too variable to be of any value. I dug into this a couple of years ago and discovered some details that seem more reliable, which are summarized in the one page file here (also as a pdf via this link: […]

Distinguishing Philadelphia and Red-eyed Vireos by song: Is it possible? Read More »

Determining age and sex of Rose-breasted Grosbeaks in spring and summer

I put together this matrix of variation in breeding plumage Rose-breasted Grosbeaks, showing the differences between each of the four age-sex classes. In this species it’s relatively easy to distinguish males from females, a little harder to distinguish one-year-old males from older males, and nearly impossible to determine the age of females. As in many

Determining age and sex of Rose-breasted Grosbeaks in spring and summer Read More »

Identification of the newest meadowlark – Chihuahuan

In their 2022 checklist supplement the AOS voted to elevate the southwestern populations of Eastern Meadowlark to a full species, with the name Chihuahuan Meadowlark. it’s been recognized as a distinctive population for decades, usually under the name Lilian’s Meadowlark, but making it a full species raises the stakes and adds new emphasis to a

Identification of the newest meadowlark – Chihuahuan Read More »

Subspecies of Common Grackle: Bronzed, Florida, and “Purple”

Common Grackle is a familiar backyard bird almost everywhere east of the Rocky Mountains, and shows some fairly striking regional variation in color. This variation involves mainly the colors of iridescence, and is most obvious in males. Females of the two extremes are readily identified, but the full range of intermediates is only apparent in

Subspecies of Common Grackle: Bronzed, Florida, and “Purple” Read More »

Finding and Identifying Stejneger’s Scoter in Alaska

Stejneger’s Scoter is the Siberian counterpart of White-winged Scoter, only recently recognized as a separate species. The two species are very similar in all respects, and only adult males can be identified readily in the field. Stejneger’s is considered a very rare visitor to western Alaska, but my experience in Nome in 2021 suggests that

Finding and Identifying Stejneger’s Scoter in Alaska Read More »

Identifying small flycatchers: Separating Elaenia and Empidonax by wing pattern

I wanted to know if I could find an objective and reliable feature that would allow me to distinguish any elaenia from any empidonax, and it turns out it’s the pattern on the folded wing. The presence or absence of pale edges on the primaries is the best single feature to focus on to be sure which genus you are looking at.

Identifying small flycatchers: Separating Elaenia and Empidonax by wing pattern Read More »